Australian Health Care Reform Alliance (AHCRA) Workshop on Mental Health and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health

Thursday, 18 February 2016
AHCRA Summit photo of Ken Wyatt
Ken Wyatt speaking at AHCRA Summit

The day before the Prime Minister made his Closing the Gap report to Parliament, the Australian Health Care Reform Alliance (AHCRA) held a policy workshop to discuss Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health and mental health. The main issues discussed during the day included the following:

  • The Gap isn’t closing and emerging data issues have led to major questions being asked as to whether anything is being achieved;
  • Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people aged 35-44 are dying at 5 times the rate of the rest of the population;
  • 80 percent of deaths in children aged 4-11 are Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children; and
  • the level of disability is at least double the rate in the broader population and is largely hidden.

Against this poor performance in Closing the Gap, cuts of $200 million have been made to the health flexible funds, further impacting the availability of health services in rural and remote communities.

There is an urgent need to re-establish the Framework for Indigenous Mental Health, which ran out in 2007 and has not been revised.  At present, one in three deaths in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people aged 13-35 is due to suicide.  However, the Ministerial Advisory Group on Aboriginal Suicide Prevention was disbanded in 2015 and funding of $85 million for Indigenous suicide prevention is now going to Primary Health Networks, not Aboriginal health providers.  This pattern is common, with 80 percent of funding for Indigenous health going to non-Indigenous groups.

The conversation regarding mental health reform began with discussion of the need for different business models for both aged care and mental health – with more upstream services, not hospital services.  There is still a tendency to equate healthcare with hospitals; but we need to think more broadly and develop appropriate outcome measures.

A consumer advocate raised the issue that often when people with a diagnosed mental health condition present in ED, they are not checked for physical symptoms but are assumed to be having mental health issues.  There need to be better protocols in ED in such situations to ensure appropriate treatment is offered at the earliest time.

Delegates spoke of the key things needed to improve mental health care and treatment in rural and remote communities:

  • consistent outcome measures for benchmarking, enabling progress to be measured and reported;
  • flexible funding that meets the needs of patients and their carers;
  • nationally consistent models of care delivered in such a way as to meet regional needs;
  • greater consumer and carer involvement; and
  • recognition that many people have been traumatised by their experiences with health care services. Models of care need to be developed to enable traumatised people to access and benefit from services.

An underlying theme of the meeting was that in both mental health and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health, there has been so much research, but so little action.  This needs to change.

Recordings of presentations from speakers will be available on the AHCRA website at